Renewing the Rivalry: Browns-Steelers Preview

The Cleveland Browns will return to the field on Sunday to host their bitter nemesis the Pittsburgh Steelers at the dawn of the DeShone Kizer Era. Expectations are muted for the Browns overall, but there is no better way to inject hope into an atrophying fanbase quite like beating the fellas in black and yellow.

Are the Browns Favored?

Continuing last year’s tradition I will continue to note whether or not the Browns are favored going into a given contest. The Browns, mirroring my tradition, held up their end of the bargain by again being home underdogs to the Steelers this time by nine points. That line feels about right considering the teams’ performances last season.

Rookie Spotlight

The excitement surrounding the season opener was doused with a cold pitcher of high ankle sprain on Wednesday when the Browns announced that first overall pick Myles Garrett suffered an injury and will miss four to six weeks. Those dreams of Garrett planting Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger will have to wait until Week 17. Still, Sunday marks the rookie debuts for two of Cleveland’s top picks from the spring’s draft. Jabril Peppers will make his debut at safety as well as kick and punt returner. He offers plenty of promise on special teams and can hopefully boast a woeful secondary as well. All eyes will also be on second round pick Deshone Kizer’s premiere under center. He is the next in a long (long, long, long) tradition of quarterbacks making their Browns debut in Week 1. No doubt he would prefer to avoid the division-favored Steelers, but what can you do.

Familiar Faces

This iteration of the rivalry involves a new wrinkle – familiar faces in different helmets. During final roster cutdowns the Browns parted with two-time Pro Bowler Joe Haden. The second-longest tenured Brown, it came as somewhat of a surprise to see Cleveland let him go. Not surprisingly, Pittsburgh jumped at the opportunity to sign him. He will start at cornerback on Sunday against a quarterback he has literally played against every day all summer long. He might have a good day.

Last week the Browns made a direct deal with the Steelers to acquire wide receiver Sammie Coates. To complete the deal Cleveland send over a 2018 sixth-round pick, a pick (and I cannot stress this enough) that the Browns originally acquired for flop cornerback Justin Gilbert. So the Harvard Brain Trust flipped the same negligible pick back to Pennsylvania for a 24-year-old wide receiver with 22 receptions, 446 yards, and two touchdowns. He is hardly Julio Jones, but it’ll be interesting to see how he fares against his old team.

Season openers have not been kind to the Browns since they returned in 1999. Their struggles in Week 1 are well documented: 1-17 in season openers, most of those losses coming at Cleveland Browns/First Energy Stadium. It’s been thirteen years since the Butch Davis-led Browns defeated the Baltimore Ravens 20-3 to kick off the 2004 season. To make matters worse the Browns have repeatedly been crushed in Week 1 over the past five years, getting outscored 130-73. They will get a chance to flip that script on Sunday.

The Browns’ unexpected 4-0 postseason run made a few waves (and inspired a few tee shirts) in the greater Cleveland area. Even if the games do not count there it is not unreasonable to believe that good habits and strong play could translate from August to September. It is worth noting, however, that preseason performance has very little correlation with regular season outcomes. In perhaps the most famous example the 2008 Detroit Lions enjoyed an undefeated preseason before dropping all of their regular season games to become the league’s only 0-16 team. On the other hand, the 2007 Patriots went 16-0 in the regular season after a 2-2 preseason run. So I would caution anyone from placing any wagers based on preseason showing.

So what does this game mean in the grand scheme of things? It’s hard to say. With Myles Garrett’s injury disrupting the defensive game plan it would be easy to put an asterisk on the game if the Browns lose a close one and wonder “what could have been” were number 95 on the field. Still, I’m looking for competitiveness. The Browns made no bones about tanking last year, and my top question is whether that was a one year experiment or a Philadelphian “Process.” Either way it’s only one game. Hell, it would just be nice to win on Opening Day for once.



  • Eric G

    I wonder if CBS will mention during their broadcast what number starter this is for the Browns since 1999?

  • Pat Leonard

    Here’s hoping that the Steelers’ defense has just as many communication failures as the Patriots’ defense had last night. It’s Week 1, anything is possible. Go Brownies.

  • Harv

    “Rivalry”? Ha. Only in the garden of the minds of local fans and clueless national broadcast guys who intone cliches about “this storied Cleveland franchise.” Play that word association in Pittsburgh and you’d get 10 teams before you’d have to interrupt to ask.

  • Eric G

    Speaking of trades, how did Cam do last night? Did he even “play”?

  • Pat Leonard

    Nope, he didn’t play any snaps with the offense. They had Fisher on the left and Schwartz on the right. Schwartz had a really good game for anyone who wants to bemoan his loss a little more.

  • mgbode

    I have already noted Kizer is the 15th Week 1 starter in 19 seasons of post-expansion Browns football, so that has to count for something. Right?

  • Eric G

    I’m pretty sure that’s been bemoaned to the fullest extent to which a bemoanment can be bemoaned.

  • Eric G

    It counts for *something*. I’ll let you decide what that something is

  • CBiscuit

    Agreed….a team that goes 14-3 since the millenium and dominates may no longer be in rival status. But enough about Ohio State and Michigan. I do think the rivalry can run deep and there are other rivalry factors involved than pure records…but I think despite the deep seeded hate…time is ticking down.

  • mgbode
  • Pat Leonard

    For whatever reason, this made me think of this line from Paul Giamatti when he was on 30 Rock.

    Now THAT’s how you bemoan.

  • MaryMBaughman

    my neighbor’s step-aunt makes $71 hourly on the internet . She has been unemployed for six months but last month her check was $21165 just working on the internet for a few hours. hop over to here