WFNY Roundtable

Sport Movie Takes: WFNY Roundtable


I’ve always loved sports movies. In fact, sports movies are how I came to start working with WFNY. I have a podcast (currently on a brief hiatus) all about sports movies, called “Anything to Add, Monty.” I first met Craig by inviting him to be a guest on our Draft Day episode, and the rest is history. If you follow WFNY on social media, you may have noticed that a certain unnamed member of the staff (Hattery) had a very silly and wrong take on our beloved favorite Major League. We all told him he was wrong (he was) but we needed to give him some other examples of great sports movies, so we came together and we’re all going to talk about them here.

What is your all-time favorite sports movie? Why is it your favorite? Do you incorporate quotes into your writing, podcasting, or daily life? Any stories about watching it with friends?

Jim: I truly don’t have a singular favorite sports movie. I pretty much like them all, whether they’re overly produced Hollywood crud, or really hard working B Movies that make them A Movies. My five favorites are Hoosiers, Bull Durham, Slapshot, Tin Cup and Field of Dreams, and they literally touch a different part of my psyche for different reasons. That said, if you made me pick one, I’d say Bull Durham, because it catches, for me, everything that is good about the actual game of baseball. I love the minors, and the quite literal differences you see every day in players. A majority of the players are the Crash Davis’s of the world…minor league lifers setting records they don’t want to set because it’s the minors. I spent almost 20 years in the Raleigh/Durham area, right after they moved from Durham Athletic Park (where the movie takes place), but have seen many games there, and love the minor league culture in the area, that was so captured in the movie. Kevin Costner’s been in some dogs, but this movie is the quintessential Costner, the smart ass who thinks he shoulda been more, and finally acknowledges what he is. Roy McAvoy is essentially the same character in Tin Cup.

Dave: Like Jim, it is really tough to pick a favorite. I’ll watch any of them, no matter how bad. One of my favorites is Little Big League, it is a great little movie, with an excellent cast, a great witty script and a very interesting plot. As far as quotes go, nothing can beat Major League. Nothing beats a well placed “Cross him off then.” or a “Shut up Dorn.” One of the aspects of my podcast that I really liked was watching a movie at the same time as my good friend John, my podcasting partner on ATAM. It was fun to see each others perspectives

Josh: I know this wasn’t asked, but I have two favorite sports movie. On the comedy side, it’s definitely Happy Gilmore; on the non-funny and true story side, it’s gotta be Blind Side. While I don’t incorporate either of them into my writing, I do say plenty of Happy Gilmore quotes into my daily life. You can never watch either of those too many times, and when I was a kid, my gamertag for Playstation 2 online was even ShooterMcGavin23, which proved how much I loved that movie. Due to the fact that I’m not much of a movie guy, I haven’t watched either movie in quite some time. But if I had to watch a movie at this moment, those two would be in my top three or four of movies I would choose.

Bode: Major League has a strong pull here, but my favorite sport’s movie is still Caddyshack. It has a terrible plot, horrific acting, the premise is nonsensical, and the worst part of the movie is the main theme (Danny Noonan’s character arc). Who cares? The movie is a fantastic series of Saturday Night Live skits complete with one-liners and punchlines throughout with the greatest collection of comedians ever assembled for major roles in a movie. The lines of this movie still being known and utilized constantly 37 years after the initial release speaks for itself. How many of us haven’t used “You’ll have nothing and like it” or “So I got that going for me, which is nice” or “Thank you very little” over and over again (among the million other catch phrases that came out of it)?

Gilbert: My all-time favorite sports movie may be unconventional, but it is Space Jam. Space Jam came out during my early childhood and so I sort of grew up on it. I use many of the quotes and moments of the movie throughout my daily life. Comparing teams to the Monstars and hoping a halftime talk contained the drinking of “Michael’s Special Stuff.” Space Jam is just a fun movie with some of the best cartoon characters of all time and one of the great athletes of all time. I love the cameos from the former NBA players and big time actors like Bill Murray. It is sort of an inspirational movie about over coming the odds and winning as the underdog. What’s not to like about Space Jam?

What is an unpopular sports movie take that you have? Is there a movie you love that others hate? Or one you hate that others seem to love? Why do is it over-or-under-rated?

Jim: I liked Draft Day. Why mince words. I’ve only seen it once. I laughed throughout because of its ridiculousness. None of the movie is true. They screw up everything, and the best part of the movie, Dennis Leary, is made to look like an asshat for having the only true take. But c’mon, think about this. Don’t you think, if anyone could manage to trade three first rounders for the first pick, then take a linebacker nobody wants until maybe 15, then trade three second rounders for the sixth pick, then use the sixth pick to trade BACK to the team who gave you the first pick, get all your first rounders back, go with the rugged quarterback you already have, and take Arian Fos…er…some running back with the No. 7 pick, it would be the Browns? This movie is ludicrous, and really sucks, and I love it for that very reason. C’mon people, it’s Hollywood…relax.

Dave: There are a few here. Slap Shot has a great first and last 10 minutes, and the middle is pretty much garbage. The Program has its problems, but is miles ahead of Any Given Sunday. The Fish That Saved Pittsburgh is definitely worth watching. Also Space Jam is one of the worst movies ever made. But, as I said in the beginning, it almost doesn’t matter how bad a sports movie is. I’ll watch it. I’ve watched The Benchwarmers multiple times, and it is painful to watch.

Josh: Caddyshack isn’t a good movie. It may just be the fact that the first (and only) time I watched the movie was when I was a little kid, but I was expecting it to be a movie I would continuously laugh at; I did the complete opposite. My thoughts on the movie may change now that I am a bit older, but I will most likely never give it another chance.1

Bode: Here is where I mention that Major League 2 gets a bad reputation mostly based on not being as grand as Major League. The main story arc around Rick “Wild Thing” Vaughn is terrible (much like Danny Noonan in Caddyshack), however there are a ton of redeemable and funny parts throughout. Rube Baker is hilarious. There is a prototypical Lou Brown angry speech about excuses that ends with “Who used heart attack? Me!” exchange. Plus, “not those Giants” was a fantastic way at introducing the Japanese outfielder into the film. Hiroshi “Kamikaze” Tanaka then winds up being the best character in the film as he runs into walls, breaks out samurai swords, and introduces the world to the marble dance as he challenges Pedro Cerrano’s manhood. Omar Epps mocking Wesley Snipes through the Willie Mays Hays character even gives an off screen tangent to add to the humor.

Gilbert: Bull Durham is one of the most overrated movies of all-time. It is just flat out boring to me. The first time I watched the movie, I was at a baseball tournament in Cooperstown. I was watching it with some of the players from the team I was there with. It took only about 20 or 30 minutes of the movie for many of the kids and me to get up and leave. These kids were baseball fanatics, too. I’m sorry I just do not understand the infatuation with that movie. But to each his own.

  1. Editor’s note: and now you know why we blame Millenials for all the problems of society. Carry on. []

  • RGB

    You’re killin’ me smalls!
    I can’t believe you guys missed it…×740

  • Eric G

    I’d probably have to go Happy Gilmore, too, though that chick’s haircut bugs me to this day, as well as her, “Happy, look out OOOHH!” delivery. Bull Durham second, though it drags.

    I never thought Field of Dreams was that great. Maybe it’s because I didn’t get into sports until I was older and I saw it during my sports-can-kick-sand days, but even when I tried to re-watch it, it was meh. Friday Night Lights, The Program, Mighty Ducks – all bad.

    Great observation on Caddyshack. I stopped watching it over and over again because I just got sick of the Danny story. Chase, Murray, and especially Dangerfield (I supposed Ted Knight, too) owned that movie. Oh, and Bode, it’s “You’ll *get* nothing and like it.” I’ll quote that movie all day still.

    Caddyshack 2 might be the worst of all. It was complete and utter trash, even with the small glimmer of humor in Akroyd’s ridiculousness.

  • MartyDaVille

    Great roundtable, guys.

    I can be a real sap at times, as evidenced by the fact that whenever I surf across Field of Dreams, I have to watch it to the end. “Dad, do you want to have a catch?” gets me every time.

    In the same vein, I love Miracle, the story of our 1980 Olympics hockey team. That’s another one that gets my allergies going.

    The Natural and Caddyshack also go on my Rushmore.

  • scripty

    I would say The Color of Money if it fits as a sports movie. If DQ’d it’d be The Natural on the sports tip and Major League on the comedy tip. Race for Your Life Charlie Brown would get Honorable Mention

  • RGB

    Technically Running Man was a sports movie.

  • tigersbrowns2

    great choice & in my monstrous movie collection.

  • tigersbrowns2

    i could watch Remember The Titans , Eight Men Out & Field Of Dreams over & over & over again … and there are many many more sports movies than you realize … Raging Bull , Seabiscuit , The Natural & Ali are some other good ones. then you have your comedies like Caddyshack , The Longest Yard , Kingpin , Happy Gilmore etc. … and then you even had a few that aren’t even real sports , like Rollerball.

  • My all-timer is Major League, and there is no dispute. Great balance of sports and comedy. That’s actually my issue with Caddyshack as a sports movie: the setting might be a golf course, but I don’t see it as a golf movie per se. I know, weird. One of the great comedies though, of course. Tin Cup, on the other hand? That’s a damn good golf movie. Other favorites by sport:

    Soccer: Victory
    Hockey: Slap Shot
    Football: Varsity Blues
    Basketball: White Men Can’t Jump
    Boxing: Rocky IV

    As for “unpopular” takes:

    -Major League 2 is actually not bad (“Women: can’t live with ’em, and they can’t pee standing up”)
    -Field of Dreams is a dull, sappy, pretty much unwatchable movie
    -The Program is absolutely ridiculous, and I will watch it whenever I find it on tv
    -I actually enjoy The Replacements
    -Space Jam is pretty lame

  • tigersbrowns2

    hi B-BO … good choices. see , now i would say the Field Of Dreams is one of the best written & acted sports films with a powerful cast … everyone will have a different opinion & that’s okay.

  • JM85

    Not sure where all the hate is coming from for Field of Dreams. I love that movie. I also will admit to enjoying Major League 2. I loved Major League and all the Rocky movies even though they got ridiculous.

  • Elizabethehallmark

    Google is paying 97$ per hour! Work for few hours and have longer with friends & family! !pa221d:
    On tuesday I got a great new Land Rover Range Rover from having earned $8752 this last four weeks.. Its the most-financialy rewarding I’ve had.. It sounds unbelievable but you wont forgive yourself if you don’t check it
    ➽➽;➽➽ http://GoogleFinancialJobsCash221OfficeMediaGetPay$97Hour ★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★:::::!pa221l..,.

  • I liked “The Hustler” better than “The Color of Money,” and had it in my top five for this, but took it out for Slapshot because of the “sports stretch theory.” Both movies are pretty spectacular…

  • Damn, I forgot about Eight Men Out…absolutely love it…

  • The hate for FoD has always sorta cracked me up. To each their own, I guess, but from a baseball fan perspective, it hits on the bare roots of baseball. There was an argument in a bar a few years ago in which someone said, “It’s not even a Damn baseball movie.” Wrong. Dead Wrong. Everything about it is every important baseball theme there is. Love it…love everything about it

  • It was there in my thoughts…

  • Crystaljsmith

    Google is paying 97$ per hour! Work for few hours and have longer with friends & family! !pa90d:
    On tuesday I got a great new Land Rover Range Rover from having earned $8752 this last four weeks.. Its the most-financialy rewarding I’ve had.. It sounds unbelievable but you wont forgive yourself if you don’t check it
    ➽➽;➽➽ http://GoogleFinancialJobsCash90TopBlueGetPay$97Hour ★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★✫★★:::::!pa90l..,.